“Of Film Critics - A Dying Breed, THANKFULLY!”
That’s what the title of this post should have been. Yesterday, I sat in a dark screening room off Times Square in Manhattan and had a lightbulb moment which finally helped me to understand one of the reasons the world is such a mess. OK, so maybe it’s not going to help find the cause for the evils caused by rotten, power-hungry leaders, and it might not solve the current economic crisis, but it does give some personal insight into the strange discrepancies that create such a disconnect between the films that are made and those that actually make it: AGE. Before my septuagenarian readers - if I have any? - get their feathers ruffled and begin shaking their heads with the unexpressed stress of the, well… aged, let me explain.
Films are typically made by thirty-something filmmakers. Some may be older, some may be younger, but from experience the average film director is typically in his/her mid-thirties. Even those who are older possess incredibly young souls and sensitivities. This is no way an ageist opinion. The audiences that most filmmakers speak to, the ones that go to movies, fill up the halls and then buy into the trends that are created by the films and the hoopla that surrounds them, are typically no older than 25. Catch any commercial film, either in the US, UK or India, at any particular showing and 90% of the audience are under 30, 40% under 20.
But then, to this hip mix, we add the film critics. Truthfully, 95% of them are over 65. And the remainder are wannabe filmmakers who would hate anything of value put in front of them, simply because they themselves never managed to find their deeply hidden talent inside. So what do we expect the film critic to bring to the table? His or her taste and knowledge. But this sensitivity is bound to be age-conscious and
talent-biased. I watched a wonderful documentary yesterday, something truly inspiring, which you’ll definitely get to read about next week on my column at Chic Today. I exited the cinema with a special light in my eyes and a fresh spring in my step, while my fellow reviewers were more worried about being to walk out of the screening room without falling over each other and getting to the bathroom first… You see my point here. I might not sound kind, but I write what I observe. I respect my elders, but there is something to be said for this particular bunch, with no manners and a sense of self-entitlement. Why? Because their readers have given it to them, that’s why!
Of course, there are sites such as Passion For Cinema which have finally given film commentary back to the audience. You’ll hardly ever find someone over 30 writing on PFC, other than that rogue fantastic filmmaker beloved by yours truly - who shall remain nameless to those who don’t get the hint herein hidden and is hardly himself a couple of years over 30 anyway! But even some of the guys - and the occasional women fans - on PFC suffer from a syndrome that affects too many of today’s film critics: criticizing.
I am a firm believer that the correct derivative of the word ‘critic’ should be ‘critiquing’, not ‘criticizing’. In critiquing, one brings to the future viewers’ attention the attributes of the film, while avoiding to give the plot away and encouraging the audience to make up their own mind in regards to the quality of the film at hand. Criticizing instead simply imposes one’s views on the readers and manages to infuse each and every film commented upon with an overly technical and sterile opinion. To me, it all about that old adage “If you have nothing good to say, say nothing at all” which is the motto I try to live my life by. Bas.
Each and every work of art has a value, simply because there was one person at the very beginning of it, with nothing more than a dream, perhaps surrounded by a few others who believed in that same dream. If we are to accept the obvious, that even a journey of a thousand miles begins with one single step, those filmmakers out there who have managed to turn that dream into a reality - or more importantly, a film - have made magic by taking that first, impossibly hard step. They are to be applauded for their efforts, though some harder and louder than others, of course. I am not in any way implying that all art should exist simply by being called art, but especially the magic we call “The Movies” needs to be accepted as a wonderful creation and not be pulled apart by some two-bit wannabe filmmaker with a half minute reel to his/her name, and definitely not by the ancient powers that be who think dying institutions such as the NY Times are the bible of truth.
Lastly, a little disclaimer. I do not, nor have ever claimed to be a journalist. I am quite happy with the term writer and proud of my lineage. I also don’t mind something that was hurled at me as an insult, that I am a promoter, not a critic. Indeed. Promoting all things great by converting one person at a time. Thank you for the compliment!!
Bookmark with: